Around menopause, weight gain isn't just an inevitable hormonal fate: diet appears to play a far more decisive role than previously thought. A major American study published in JAMA Network Open has just compared several types of menopause diets and identified those that truly limit the pounds gained during this pivotal period.
A Study of Nearly 40,000 Women Over 30 Years
Researchers drew on the Nurses' Health Study II cohort, which followed 38,283 American women, averaging 45.6 years old, between 1989 and 2019. The goal: to measure weight changes during the six years before and after menopause, based on the type of diet followed. Contrary to more widely publicized diets like the low-carb diet or the classic Mediterranean diet, these were not the models that came out on top.
The Two Diets That Best Limit Weight Gain
Two approaches stand out: the low insulinemic index diet and the Planetary Health diet, both based on minimally processed plant foods. Among women most closely following a diet with low insulin-secretion impact, the reduction in observed weight gain averages 0.28 kg less per year compared to the least favorable dietary profiles — a gap that widens over several years.
- Low in red meat and processed meats
- Low in potatoes and sodium
- High in legumes, nuts, fruits, vegetables, and whole grains
This finding echoes data published this year by the nutrition barometer from Santé publique France (France's public health agency), which already pointed to the gap between recommended dietary guidelines and what the French actually eat.
Why Does the Insulinemic Index Matter So Much?
The faster a food causes insulin secretion to spike, the more it is thought to promote fat storage, particularly during the hormonal upheavals of menopause. Conversely, a diet that limits insulin spikes would help the body better regulate its weight without requiring strict calorie restriction. This logic is in line with personalized nutrition approaches without calorie counting that are gaining ground, where the focus is on food quality rather than quantity.
What This Means in Practice
No need for an extreme diet: researchers emphasize that these are gradual, sustainable adjustments, not deprivation. Swapping some refined starches and processed meats for legumes, nuts, and whole grains is enough to change the weight trajectory over several years. This type of dietary support is, moreover, increasingly discussed in medical consultations, including for the broader hormonal issues covered in our full report on menopause.
To learn more about overall dietary balance and physical activity, the Health & Medicine and Fitness & Wellness sections of the site offer other useful guidance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Mediterranean Diet No Longer Recommended, Then?
It remains a recognized healthy foundation, but the study shows it is not the most protective specifically against weight gain during menopause, unlike low insulinemic index or Planetary Health-type diets.
Should Red Meat Be Eliminated Entirely?
The study does not call for total elimination but rather a reduction in red meat and processed meat consumption, in favor of plant-based proteins like legumes.
Does This Type of Diet Apply Outside of Menopause?
The core principles — fewer ultra-processed foods, more whole plant foods — are generally recommended at any age, even though this study specifically targets the menopausal transition period.
Sources
Medscape — Planetary Health Diet May Lower Obesity Risk at Menopause
Healio — Plant-based, low-insulinemic diets may be best for mitigating weight gain during menopause
Profil de l'auteur
Derniers articles
DIY & Troubleshooting18 November 2026Dexter Sander Recall 2026: What Leroy Merlin and Weldom Customers Need to Know Before Using It
Restaurants, Drinks & Food18 November 2026Flexitarianism in France: Less Meat on the Plate, but Not for the Reasons You'd Think
Home Appliances & Equipment18 November 2026Washing Machine, Oven, Dishwasher: Which Brand to Choose for Appliances That Last?
Nutrition, Diet & Weight Loss18 November 2026Pancreatic Fat: The Diet That May Help Reduce It
Trending now on legal streaming
FilmThe Odyssey
SeriesThe Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power
This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy
Table of Contents





